Page 1 of 1
Recent media interview on Food Pyramid Dietary Guidelines
Posted: Thu Jul 15, 2010 1:15 pm
by BrightAngel
Some of you might be interested in watching this interview.
http://www.myfoxdc.com/dpp/mornings/cel ... nes-071410
Re: Recent media interview on Food Pyramid Dietary Guideline
Posted: Thu Jul 15, 2010 10:18 pm
by Clarica
I didn't buy his premise--that americans are eating as the food pyramid suggests. I don't know if the food pyramid is good enough, brilliant, or sub-standard, but I just don't think that people are fat because they are following it. Some might be, I grant you. :)
Posted: Fri Jul 16, 2010 12:05 am
by dmarie710
That was really good. Thank You BrightAngel. I know for myself, if I ate as much as the food pyramid tells me I need I would be as big as a house. I actually tried that and they wanted me to eat 1800 cal/day, if I'm remembering correctly. When I saw that, I knew that they were way off base.
Re: Recent media interview on Food Pyramid Dietary Guideline
Posted: Fri Jul 16, 2010 12:24 pm
by wosnes
Clarica wrote:
I didn't buy his premise--that americans are eating as the food pyramid suggests. I don't know if the food pyramid is good enough, brilliant, or sub-standard, but I just don't think that people are fat because they are following it. Some might be, I grant you.
I agree. I can't think of anyone I know who follows the food pyramid recommendations. I can think of a lot of people who couldn't tell you anything about the food pyramid -- from how it's organized to how many servings are recommended in each group.
not objective
Posted: Sat Jul 17, 2010 7:32 pm
by paulawylma
Thanks for the link BrightAngel. I just watched the clip and I laughed when he claimed that Americans have been following the food pyramid. He makes a good point that different people have different needs and actually the last time I visited the usda website I couldn't just print out a list of requirements--I had to put in data so that it could be customized.
Dr Feinman kept talking about carbs and low fat foods as though that's all the food pyramind is. The food pyramid also tells people to eat fruits and vegetables (just two examples)--which I am confident that most of us are not eating enough of. I know I don't eat the minimum vegs and fruits on a daily basis--because I tried and unless I eat a salad or stir-fry everyday, I ended up short.
I clicked on the link to Dr Feinman's organization and it turns out that the society isn't as objective as it sounded. The only diet information they offer is low carb and the website repeats the mantra that the typical American Diet is High carb/low fat. That's not true, The typical American diet is high-processed carb/high fat/high sugar (yes, I know sugar is a carb but I wanted to distinguish it from grains and vegetable starches).
I'm glad that No S leaves nutrition to intelligent defaults rather than getting on one bandwagon or another.