CAN I HAVE A SMALL DESSERT AFTER EVENING MEAL

[L A]

I'D PREFER TO HAVE A SMALL DESSERT DAILY THAN CHANGE MY EATING PLAN AT WEEKENDS. IS THAT OK?

[~reneew]

You know it's not the basic plan, but you can make mods. I say, whatever works for you, but only after accomplishing the straight up plan successfully for a while. I recommend reading the post written by KCCC (I think) about the phases of NoS.

[leafy_greens]

I'D PREFER TO HAVE A SMALL DESSERT DAILY THAN CHANGE MY EATING PLAN AT WEEKENDS. IS THAT OK?

No.

[oolala53]

I've read Reinhard say you can do whatever you want, but it won't really be No S. Limiting sweets to weekends was carefully determined, as were the other S's.

From my experience here and on other sites (one thread devoted to ending bingeing), clinging to a daily sweet is the source of more downfalls than just about anything else I've seen. Not to say there aren't exceptions. But for those who have made a habit of overeating, successfully limiting themselves to a small daily sweet is the exception.

[ksbrowne]

L A,
That's what I do. It works for me. It took a bit of practice for me to get to stop after one small serving. But it's not an issue anymore. Sometimes I have a cookie, other times a scoop of ice cream, or a piece of chocolate.

[Eeyore]

If you would have asked me a couple years back I would have told you yes, without any hesitation...but now...I say it's a slippery slope. I've restarted NoS numerous times and the only reason it's sticking now is because I've kept it simple (with the exception of starting my S days on Fri @ 5pm & ending Sun @ 5pm).

The reasons I failed miserably the other times was I was either too strict, doing another diet with NoS, or just making it more complicated. The small dessert isn't really an issue but it's what it can become. I remember allowing myself a fruit in between lunch and dinner, that fruit became a 100 calorie pack snack, which became a couple cookies or a slice of cake. Not to mention chaotic S days couldn't occur because I was only afforded one dessert. This may seem ok for some but this restriction led to me bingeing, it started to feel too much like a diet.

I say if you eat your dessert at the same time everyday and make it a habit it could work. If all else fails take a step back to vanilla NoS.

[osoniye]

I'd say try it, and set yourself an exact time limit, say one month, and if it is working at that point, good for you keep it up. If you find that just really doesn't work for you in real life, then give vanilla NoS a try, and then you can compare.

[Lady Crimson]

I'D PREFER TO HAVE A SMALL DESSERT DAILY THAN CHANGE MY EATING PLAN AT WEEKENDS. IS THAT OK?

If your dessert is a piece of fruit and it fits on your dinner plate then yes, you can. According to Vanilla No S you can't eat after the meal but you can have fruit with your meal and eat it last.

You didn't specify what "desert" is but everyone seemed to assume that it was a sweet. You cannot have a sweet but in many other countries, fruit is a dessert--fruit used to be a dessert in this country as well. Of course you can't sweeten the fruit but if the fruit is ripe and in season, it should be naturally sweet. Why not try ending your meal with orange slices or a clemantine?

[wosnes]

I'D PREFER TO HAVE A SMALL DESSERT DAILY THAN CHANGE MY EATING PLAN AT WEEKENDS. IS THAT OK?

If your dessert is a piece of fruit and it fits on your dinner plate then yes, you can. According to Vanilla No S you can't eat after the meal but you can have fruit with your meal and eat it last.

You didn't specify what "desert" is but everyone seemed to assume that it was a sweet. You cannot have a sweet but in many other countries, fruit is a dessert--fruit used to be a dessert in this country as well. Of course you can't sweeten the fruit but if the fruit is ripe and in season, it should be naturally sweet. Why not try ending your meal with orange slices or a clemantine?

I think fruit can be sweetened if you like or if it needs it. You're unlikely to use as much sugar to sweeten some fruit as you would in a pie or cake or other dessert. It really depends on how much sugar you're using and whether or not you consider it a "sweet."